Wednesday, July 26, 2006
A Little Perspective
Mount Scopus, Jerusalem, Israel
5:36 PM Israel Time
There's so little time left here. I can't believe that I'm leaving this all so soon. I feel like I'm finally starting to understand things, finally starting to get a feel for life here, starting to learn the language, starting to know the Israelis. I'm running into the same people on the street, talking to people I recognize from random bus trips or conversations in cafes. It's different now. Things are a little less new to me, but no less interesting.
The best way I can describe it is with the Islamic call to prayer. Five times a day, every mosque in the city projects a man singing, calling all Muslims to pray. It happens before sunrise, around 12:30, in the afternoon, after sunset, and late in the evening. When I first came here, there was so much mystery about the prayer. It was so new and foreign to me. And it's still a beautiful thing to hear, but I expect it now. I don't even bat an eye when we hear it through the windows during class. And it's the same with other things. The sound of gunfire in the distance, at any time of day, is something I've come to expect. No one even talks about it now. Helicopters fly overhead, at all hours. Monks eat in the cafeteria. Some guy on the street thinks he's the High Priest. People carry around automatic rifles. So?
The best way I can describe it is that I feel a distinct break coming so soon... it's not that something's ending but just that I'm leaving it. It's not a vacation anymore in the way that a person might come and see things and leave and keep the experience in a little plastic vial of water from the Jordan River. This has changed my life, in ways that I don't think I could explain to you on a website.
The word on the streets is that of chaos now. People are simultaneously hailing the beginning of World War III, a new Palestinian State, the Third Temple Period. We were at the Western Wall the other day, staring up toward the Dome of the Rock, and my friend said quietly to me, "Wow, can you believe that the Temple once stood right up there?" A young Jewish guy, no more than 30, who had been listening walked over and put his hand on my friend's shoulder, smiling. "It'll be there again real soon, real soon." The feeling among all is that something is going to happen soon, any day, whether it's a suicide bombing or an all-out war or the coming of the Messiah. CNN says that 120,000 people are in Eilat right now in the south, mostly refugees from the north. Another suicide bomber was just caught in Tel Aviv. My roommate's mom was driving there and she was sitting in traffic that had come to a dead stop when she saw a woman surrounded by military and police officers literally thrown into the back of a van before it sped away. Three others were arrested, along with several others in Jerusalem. This morning I woke up at about 5 AM to wailing sirens that seemed to surround the school, and when I walked over to the window on the third floor to look down toward the Old City, I saw flashing lights. My friends have family in bomb shelters. I've met Israelis who can't go home because the roads are blocked off.
And I've experienced things, just tiny little isolated incidents, that I don't imagine I could ever forget. I went to Yad Vashem yesterday with my friend Alison. Yad Vashem is the Holocaust Museum of Israel, a huge complex of buildings and memorials centered around the "Hall of Names", a cylindical room that holds in binders stored around the entire room the names and information about every Jew who perished in the Holocaust.
That museum really hit hard, I think. I mean, I've been here awhile, and I'm studying at the state university of Israel that pretty much represents Zionism in its finest, so I'm obviously pro-Israel in a lot of ways. But I don't think I even had a clue what the existence of Israel means to Jews. Think about what it means to finally have a country to call your own after centuries of exile? I mean, can you imagine the entire Jewish population of Poland, a community of 3.4 million, completely wiped out? This isn't the place for me to muse over the totally bewildering nature of modern anti-semitism, not to mention the murder of 6 million Jews, but just for a moment imagine the displacement of that many people and that way of life. And suddenly, Israel could become theirs. They were offered an Israeli state in Uganda, did you know that? But it was this place, this Promised Land, and this Jerusalem that they desired. Their Temple Mount was here. And now they could be here too. So many Jews have made aliyah (immigrated) to Israel. (I met a girl today, just 18, who moved here from London a month ago. In four weeks she's marrying a 19-year old in the Army, a guy who's fighting in the north right now.) The Hebrew language has been resurrected after having only existed on paper for some 2000 years. And here, finally, the Jews have a place where their religion and their state and their way of life can be one and the same, the way it was in Biblical times.
But I began to question what I was feeling. Was it entirely pity for the Jews that I was feeling, or was I also caught up in a more sweeping emotion, an emotion that was being poked and pricked: a deep hatred for Nazi Germany?
And in a moment, the complexities of politics returned.
After the Holocaust Museum, we took a bus over to Mea Shearim, a neighborhood northwest of the Old City inhabited strictly by ultra-ultra-Orthodox Jews.
This is a whole different world. The streets are unpaved and filled with rocks. People are dirt poor. They wear clothing in tatters. Women and children wear clothes clearly homemade, with the same dull blues and blacks and smoky browns you would imagine to find in peasantry Eastern-Europe. Modern life is shunned. Alleyways and staircases are falling apart. Behind each run-down house is an inner courtyard which connects many of the buildings and opens into a communal area where children sit and play jacks and women dry clothes above. It's like stepping back in time into an 18th-century Polish ghetto.
You can't get anywhere close to the neighborhood, if you're a man, unless you're wearing pants and a long-sleeve shirt, and you need to cover your head. (The dress code for women is even more strict, and women cannot walk alone safely.) I was wearing the nicest pants I had with a white dress shirt and nice shoes. Alison and I walked over to a little store before we got near to Mea Shearim and I bought a kippah. Yes, that's right, a yamekah, one of those little circular pieces of cloth that many Jewish men wear on their heads. So I was fully decked out... but it still wasn't enough. I still felt out of place because my pants were brown instead of black. The moment we got in there I felt completely separate from everything, sticking out like a sore thumb.
I've heard from multiple people that you can be stoned in this neighborhood. If you drive through their streets on Shabbat, "they will throw rocks at your car." People have died here. And the neighborhood has been the target of its share of suicide bombings. As we walked down the street, there was a man, probably a Christian, running, literally running, through the street, wearing shorts and a t-shirt. I caught him in the photo above... you can see him way in the back if you enlarge the picture. I don't know if someone was chasing him, but people were yelling as he ran past.
You see, in Mea Shearim Jews don't believe that Israel has a right to exist. They believe that, unless the Messiah brings it, an Israeli state cannot exist on the Earth. Signs posted throughout say "Long live Palestine" and other such things. Streets fall into disrepair, and when something explodes, no one really cleans up after it. You see, the Kingdom is going to come so soon! Hatred for Israel is intense here. People have died. Some residents go so far as to reject Hebrew as a spoken language, calling it a language of the Holy Books, and speaking only in Yiddish.
Photography is highly disliked in Mea Shearim. I took about 10 pictures, and each one I had to try to take without anyone seeing me.
Most Jews despise this neighborhood and the people who live here. In every conversation I had with informed Jews about this topic, they said things like, "I can't believe you went there. People get stoned there all the time."
I was talking to a couple of my friends today. We were discussing our views on this whole trip. We've met a lot of interesting people, and a lot of very religious and dutiful people, but our experience with people who have something to say about their actual connection to God is only contained to a few people in random places. A lot of my dialogue with Jews has been informative, but 99% of the time it's focused on the State of Israel and global politics, rather than on the state of their relationship with God. Everyone has a political agenda to push. With almost every person I've met, a lot of the Jews who moved here from Europe or America believe that Jews have a superior claim to sole occupancy of the Holy Land. Racism is rampant here. Arabs are feared irrationally, to the point where very few of my Jewish friends would even consider walking around a Muslim part of town. The other night we were in the Old City and we were going to take a shortcut to the Jewish Quarter through the Muslim Quarter, and a couple of the girls we were with, when they discovered where we were going, simply freaked out. They've been taught their whole lives that the Muslim Quarter is dangerous and off-limits. In our discussions on their religion, they've focused mainly on their fear of some sort of attack from Muslims. And most of my talks with Christians here have focused mainly on their sense of undeserved minority in the city and their exclusion from politics, like they're not allowed to play the game but they really want to. Get off it, guys! You don't need to look for people to hate too!
I've discovered that, personally, I believe that both Jews and Arabs have very legitimate claims to this part of the world. Muslims have lived here for the last 1300 years. They have holy sites here and they have family here and they have lives here. I don't understand how people can feel so divided when they each pray to the same God, each Faith traditionally branching back to the same Abraham. It's the same God, my friends. It's the same Biblical characters, the same stories. Muslims and Christians and Jews pray to the same Yahweh. This is undeniable fact. You walk through the Old City and you walk down the same street and you pass through boundaries to three different quarters. Through each quarter, people around you are reaching out to God in the way they learned how. What is this battle they're fighting? Their Holy City is divided down arbitrary boundaries, with churches and mosques and synagogues and holy sites sometimes standing inconveniently beyond the borders of their religious quarter. Bethlehem is illegal for Israelis to enter, and today most Christians will never see the Church of the Nativity. Palestinian-controlled areas like Jericho are segregated and divided. The security fence splinters through the West Bank. Checkpoints restrict vehicular access to many small towns. But in each neighborhood, the truly Faithful each seek desparately to connect with the same God.
And there are some people in this city who do have a real connection to God. In Jerusalem there are Jews who have studied the Bible for decades, every day of their lives, and know each word by heart. Some of these people have connections to God which don't depend on a forced sense of political superiority but rather on humility and prayer. Some have connections to their ancient traditions that don't rely on a hatred for Nazi Germany but rather on a sense of survival and deliverance in the tradition of the Exodus from Egypt. And some have a love for their neighbors that looks beyond religion and seeks to know each person by the way they live rather than on the color of their skin or the way they pronounce the name of God.
These people are few.





































































































































